Wednesday One-Shot: If You Feel Like You're Being Watched, You Probably Are
15x13: To The Men Who Hurt My Mother
15x12: One Night Stand
Wednesday One-Shot: Creepy Hermits of the Woods
15x11: Why I Have a Fear of Windows
15x10: The Smile That Haunts Me
Wednesday One-Shot: Letters on the Refrigerator
15x09: My "Magic" Mirror
15x08: To My 6th Grade Teacher
Wednesday One-Shot: The Owls Are Not What They Seem
15x07: God Said I Belonged to Him
15x06: Family From Hell
Wednesday One-Shot: Middle-School Imposter
15x05: The Bottom of the Canyon
15x04: Chased Through the Utah Desert
Wednesday One-Shot: Date with a Psychopath?
15x03: Scariest Lyft Ride I've Ever Given
15x02: Girl Unknown
15x01: He Tried to Pay us to Make a Baby
14x27: A Decade of Stalking
14x26: He Knew Too Much
14x25: He Shows Up Every Night
14x24: A Crime of Passion and Revenge
14x23: Shady Teenage Best Friend
14x22: The Knock at the Back Door
14x21: Internet Girlfriend
14x20: Trail of Blood
14x19: Someone in the Woods (feat. Mike Lobel)
14x18: Fear Thy Neighbor
14x17: I Think My Ex Tried to Kill Me
14x16: The Sinister Apartment (feat. Kaydra Brannan)
14x15: Eyes of the Forest
14x14: My Coworker Became My Worst Nightmare
14x13: My Brother and the Cult
14x12: The Leprechaun Impersonator Almost Kidnapped Us!
14x11: Plans For Murder
14x10: A Robbery and a Murder
14x09: We Unknowingly Stayed at a Cult Leader's House
14x08: The Best of Canine Hero Stories
14x07: Craigslist Creep
14x06: I Never Want to Meet My Best Friend Again (feat. Scaroline)
14x05: Creepy Weed Dealer
14x04: The Body at the Dam
14x03: Cemetery Girl
14x02: Don't Take Candy From a Kidnapper
14x01: My New Friend is a Cult Recruiter
13x26: The Best of Holiday Scares
13x25: My Sinister MSN Crush
13x24: I Moved In With My Stalker
13x23: Pizza Shop Creep
next page