BONUS: Menendez Brothers Resentencing Press Conference Reaction
On October 16, 2024, the family of Lyle Menendez and Erik Menendez had a press conference in downtown Los Angeles. As victims of the murders under Marsy's Law, the family members then went to court to be heard in the decision of resentencing. John Thrasher and Daryn Carp react to the news conference and what this means for the Menendez Brothers. SIGN THE PETITION: https://www.justiceforerikand...
15m Oct 17, 2024
15m
#178 - Fatal Love Triangle
After an on-again off-again relationship finally ends, Kaitlin Armstrong can't stand the idea of her ex moving on from her. SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! (http://youtube.com/@shakenanddisturbed) Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on Patreon! Patreon members can join us during our live recordings, comment on the case, participate in polls and ge...
33m Oct 13, 2024
33m
NMR #72 - John Dreamed About Matt
John had a dream about Matt The Bartender, a former colleague and reindeer. Halloween month kicked off with both John and Daryn attending Halloween events. One was scaring while the other was scared! SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! (http://youtube.com/@shakenanddisturbed) Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on Patreon! Patreon members can join us ...
31m Oct 11, 2024
31m
#177 - "The Menendez Brothers" Netflix Documentary (Reaction)
Early episode alert! Special thank you to Netflix for giving us early press screeners to access this new documentary so we can bring you our reaction and review FIRST! As such, this episode of Shaken and Disturbed will be released simultaneously on Patreon and publicly! On this episode, we react to the incredible new documentary, "The Menendez Brothers," coming to Netflix on October 7. Everyon...
1hr 2m Oct 03, 2024
1hr 2m
Wake Up, It's Time To Die (Flashback)
When a man goes from hurting animals to killing people, his quiet, calm confessions sends chills down the spines of people who knew him. SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! (http://youtube.com/@shakenanddisturbed) Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on Patreon! Patreon members can join us during our live recordings, comment on the case, participate in...
33m Sep 29, 2024
33m
#176 - The Staircase: Was It The Owl?
We finally made our way to rehashing the details of Michael Peterson and his wife Kathleen, who died at the bottom of the steps. Was it Michael who killed her? Was it an intruder? Was it an accident? Was it an owl? Made famous by the HBO series "The Staircase," we weigh in on the case that left a woman dead and the rest of us asking questions. SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! (htt...
35m Sep 22, 2024
35m
NMR #71 - Woke Up Screaming
Daryn reveals that she played the X-Men video game thinking something that makes absolutely no sense. Can you tell John is writing this description? John had a nightmare the other night thanks to watching TikTok in bed. SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! (http://youtube.com/@shakenanddisturbed) Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on Patreon! Patreon ...
37m Sep 20, 2024
37m
#175 - The Mystery of the Natalie Wood
What happened to one of Hollywood's most promising young stars? When Natalie Wood is found floating in a lake all eyes point to her husband, Robert Wagner. But with actor Christopher Walken also on the boat the night Natalie Wood went missing, investigators and the public alike had questions. So what truly happened in this unsettling and disturbing case? SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YO...
42m Sep 15, 2024
42m
#174 - The Broomstick Murders
In the quiet town of Rosebud, Texas, Kenneth McDuff grew up as a notorious bully, feared by many, with a family that often enabled his bad behavior. After serving time, he was eventually paroled, only to embark on a brutal killing spree that terrorized Texas for years. SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! (http://youtube.com/@shakenanddisturbed) Watch and listen to this and every oth...
31m Sep 08, 2024
31m
NMR #70 - Why Does Taking A Walk Cost One Hundred Dollars?
Why is everything so expensive? No we want answers. From taking a walk to drinking ginger ale, everything needs to chill. John also recaps his time in New York and the humidity that caused him to feel like wet garbage. SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! (http://youtube.com/@shakenanddisturbed) Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on Patreon! Patreon m...
41m Sep 05, 2024
41m
#173 - Her Best Friends Killed Her
When Sarah Sterns went missing in New Jersey, friends and family scoured beaches and towns looking for her. But imagine the surprise when two of the most unlikeliest of suspects emerge during the investigation. SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! (http://youtube.com/@shakenanddisturbed) Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on Patreon! Patreon members c...
33m Sep 01, 2024
33m
#172 - "Face to Face with Scott Peterson" (Reaction)
John and Daryn react to the new Peacock documentary "Face to Face with Scott Peterson." What new information was revealed? Do they think Scott is Guilty or Not Guilty? And most importantly, why? Could Scott have really killed his pregnant wife Laci Peterson without any forensic evidence linking him to the murder whatsoever? SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! (http://youtube.com/@sha...
1hr 3m Aug 25, 2024
1hr 3m
NMR #69 - Andy's Wax Figure Is Too Real
John is using his platform to insist that people stop engaging in friendships using ONLY emoji! Daryn talks about her boss Andy Cohen's wax figure being a little too real! SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! (http://youtube.com/@shakenanddisturbed) Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on Patreon! Patreon members can join us during our live recordings, ...
36m Aug 22, 2024
36m
#171 - The Cleveland Torso Murders
When body parts of various victims start showing up all over the Cleveland area, police are feeling the pressure to figure out who it is. And why it's happening. Called everything from "The Cleveland Torso Murders," to "The Mad Butcher of Kingsbury Run," this case captivated the Cleveland area in the late part of the 1930s. SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! (http://youtube.com/@sha...
37m Aug 18, 2024
37m
#170 - Horror In Knoxville
In the winter of 2007, Channon Christian and Christopher Newsom Jr. fell victim to a horrific carjacking incident that spiraled into one of the largest scandals in Knoxville history. Both young adults, Channon and Chris, were abducted and murdered by a group led by Lemaricus Davidson. This episode explores the tragic events, the subsequent trials, and the lasting impact on their families and th...
30m Aug 11, 2024
30m
NMR #68 - John Reacts To Daryn's Bug Bites (Disturbing OMG)
Daryn sent John a pic of the insect attack that she endured, and he reacted, live on the show. SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! (http://youtube.com/@shakenanddisturbed) Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on Patreon! Patreon members can join us during our live recordings, comment on the case, participate in polls and get shout outs! Join for as lit...
29m Aug 08, 2024
29m
#169 - Our Favorite Episodes: Which Case Wins The Gold?
We're doing our own version of the Olympics this week with our favorite episodes! Both John and Daryn count down their own personal top 5 favorite episodes, and awarding a Bronze, Silver and of course a Gold medal! You might be surprised by which cases made the cut. What are your Gold, Silver and Bronze medal cases from Shaken and Disturbed? SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! (http:...
38m Aug 04, 2024
38m
#168 - Botched: The Bloody Dr. Brown
Dr. John Brown was a renowned surgeon for transgender people, but eventually became known for his operating table in his garage. Things only get worse for him, until eventually his lethal malpractice catches up with him. SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! (http://youtube.com/@shakenanddisturbed) Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on Patreon! Patreon...
42m Jul 28, 2024
42m
NMR #67 - Gold Medal on The Hobby Horse
John gives his Twisters review and shares his excitement for Deadpool & Wolverine. Daryn decides she will compete in the 2028 Olympics on the Hobby Horse. SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! (http://youtube.com/@shakenanddisturbed) Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on Patreon! Patreon members can join us during our live recordings, comment on the ca...
28m Jul 25, 2024
28m
#167 - The Starkweather Rampage
In the mid 1950s, Charles Starkweather took his girlfriend Caril on a multi-day rampage across Nebraska and Wyoming. But was Caril a victim of Starkweather's crimes, or did she know more than she was letting on? SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! (http://youtube.com/@shakenanddisturbed) Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on Patreon! Patreon members ...
35m Jul 21, 2024
35m
Hollywood Horror In NYC (Flashback)
Taking a week off while John is on vacation! Back next week with all new episodes! What happens when Hollywood horror meets real-life horror? After working as an expert on the 1973 horror classic "The Exorcist," a man named Paul Bateson went on to commit horrific atrocities of his own, targeting gay men in the 70s in New York City. SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! (http://youtube...
36m Jul 14, 2024
36m
#166 - The Pickton Pig Farm Massacres
In the mid 90s, Robert Pickton turned an old slaughter house on a pig farm into a dance club among other things. But when local women started going missing, it was soon revealed what meat was actually being processed on this farm. SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! (http://youtube.com/@shakenanddisturbed) Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on Patreo...
32m Jul 07, 2024
32m
#165 - The Truth About Crystal
After 14-year-old Crystal Champagne is murdered, the police turn their attention to her 21-year-old cousin Damon. But could the man who spent day and night looking for his missing cousin be the one who murdered her as well? SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! (http://youtube.com/@shakenanddisturbed) Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on Patreon! Patr...
29m Jun 30, 2024
29m
NMR #66 - How Do We Make Friends!?
John wants to be friends with someone but he's worried he'll come off as a loser or like he's hitting on someone! Daryn has more plane complaints! SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! (http://youtube.com/@shakenanddisturbed) Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on Patreon! Patreon members can join us during our live recordings, comment on the case, part...
34m Jun 27, 2024
34m
#164 - The Dixmoor Disaster
When 14-year-old Cateresa Matthews was abducted and murdered, 5 teenagers were charged and convicted. But many years later, after DNA profiling advanced, new evidence came to light that turned this case upside down. Known as The Dixmoor 5, the justice system clearly did not get this right. SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! (http://youtube.com/@shakenanddisturbed) Watch and listen ...
38m Jun 23, 2024
38m
#163 - Beauty Queen Brutality
Anita Cobby, a former beauty queen and aspiring nurse, vanished after a night out in Australia, sparking a massive search and community outrage. As details of her abduction and murder emerged, the investigation intensified, revealing shocking truths. The ensuing trial gripped the nation, with confessions and shifting blame among the suspects, leaving a lasting impact on Anita's family and the p...
32m Jun 16, 2024
32m
NMR #65 - Spiders Need To Stop
We're back! Daryn recaps her vacation in Hawaii, which included wildlife that she both wanted and didn't want to see. John wants adults to just have more fun! You can watch this episode in video form exclusively on Patreon! SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! (http://youtube.com/@shakenanddisturbed) Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on Patreon! Pat...
38m Jun 13, 2024
38m
The Hidden Gunshot Wound (Flashback)
Okay this is ACTUALLY our last week of flashbacks for a while. Daryn opens the show with an update. This is The Hidden Gunshout Wound, from last year. When one woman is found shot and killed in her bed and another man is missing, authorities look at a member of the local community theatre to try to figure out what happened. But when an autopsy reveals a surprising detail, the search for the ki...
36m Jun 09, 2024
36m
The Bleeding Suitcase (Flashback)
We took a week off from recording for Memorial Day here in the U.S. Plus Daryn is in Hawaii! Back next week with all new episodes! When a cab driver notices a suitcase is bleeding in to the trunk of his car and the 2 people who loaded it have disappeared, it sets off a manhunt in Bali, Indonesia. SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! (http://youtube.com/@shakenanddisturbed) Watch and...
42m Jun 02, 2024
42m
#162 - The Predator of Predators
Stephen Marshall's tumultuous life took a dark turn when, armed with a list of names from Maine's public sex offender registry, he embarked on a deadly mission. In April 2006, Stephen murdered multiple convicted sex offenders before authorities closed in on him. This episode delves into the chaotic events leading up to his final act of violence, his troubled past, and the chilling details of hi...
38m May 24, 2024
38m
#161 - Stories of Survival with Caitlin Van Mol, host of "Lived To Tell"
This week John and Daryn are joined by John's friend and former colleague Caitlin van Mol. Caitlin is the host of the podcast "Lived To Tell" which shares stories of people who have survived some of the most horrific things you've ever heard. Some of them are crime stories, and as you'll hear in this episode, some of them are situations you would never think would happen to you. Caitlin is the ...
46m May 19, 2024
46m
NMR #64 - Did Daryn Just Ruin John's Life?
In this episode, John is PISSSSSSSED. Daryn met, talked to, and smelled David Archuleta. John reacts. Spoiler alert: it's not pretty. To watch this episode in video form, sign up for ANY tier on Patreon right here! (http://patreon.com/shakenanddisturbed) SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! (http://youtube.com/@shakenanddisturbed) Watch and listen to this and every other episode sev...
31m May 16, 2024
31m
#160 - The Mother of Mayhem
This is the tragic true crime story of Andrew Bagby, a medical student with aspirations to become a surgeon, whose life was tormented by his troubled ex-partner, Shirley Turner. This week, we delve into the devastating aftermath for Andrew's family, particularly the legal battle over their grandson, Zachary, culminating in a heartbreaking conclusion that spurred changes in bail reform and an aw...
39m May 12, 2024
39m
Scott Peterson Update (New Evidence and New Trial) (Flashback)
We're taking this week off while we are traveling for work. Here's the Scott Peterson episode, number 98, from December 2022! Back next week with all new episodes! There's new evidence and information being brought forth lately regarding Scott Peterson's trial, including evidence that could land him a new trial all together. John and Daryn recap the Scott Peterson case, the new evidence that h...
45m May 05, 2024
45m
#159 - Who Did This To Billie-Jo?
In this episode, we delve into the tragic case of Billie-Jo Jenkins, a foster child found brutally murdered in 1997 in East Sussex. After her foster father, Sion Jenkins, was initially convicted, new evidence led to retrials and an eventual acquittal, leaving many questions unanswered. We talk about the complexities of forensic evidence, the impact of public perception, and the ongoing search f...
34m Apr 28, 2024
34m
NMR #63 - Daryn Meets Jodie Foster
This week, John thanks all of you for tagging him hundreds of times in both the Spice Girls reunion video and David Archuleta singing on American Idol. Daryn meets her own American Idol, Jodie Foster, during none other than Lesbian Visibility Week. SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! (http://youtube.com/@shakenanddisturbed) Watch and listen to this and every other episode several da...
31m Apr 26, 2024
31m
#158 - The Appalachian Massacres (Harpe Brothers)
Trigger Warning: This episode contains descriptions of extreme violence including violence against children. Listener discretion is advised. Buckle up and listen to the dark and tumultuous lives of Micajah and Wiley Harpe, two figures born in Scotland and raised during the American Revolution as British loyalists. From joining loyalist gangs as teenagers to their final days evading the law, th...
39m Apr 21, 2024
39m
#157 - Who Murdered Marilyn Sheppard?
In this episode, we delve deeper into the infamous 1954 murder of Marilyn Sheppard, an event that unraveled in Bay Village, Ohio, and ignited a nationwide media storm. We examine the initial night of the crime, the intense scrutiny faced by her husband, Sam Sheppard, and the dramatic legal battles that followed, including a conviction, a subsequent overturning on appeal, and a retrial. Through ...
36m Apr 14, 2024
36m
#156 - Is Scott Peterson Innocent? (with Attorney Sara Azari)
Daryn takes the wheel solo on this week's interview episode! Is Scott Peterson innocent? On this episode, friend of Daryn's, attorney and host of the podcast "The Presumption," Sara Azari, comes to talk about everything she knows about the case, the likelihood of Scott being found not guilty, and all the pitfalls of public opinion influencing cases. You don't want to miss the captivating conver...
53m Apr 07, 2024
53m
NMR #62 - John's Clone Joins The Show
Is that John or John's clone at the top of the show? Tune in to find out. John talks about the updates to his car that drove himself home from a haircut. Daryn has yet ANOTHER gym problem! SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! (http://youtube.com/@shakenanddisturbed) Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on Patreon! Patreon members can join us during our ...
38m Apr 04, 2024
38m
#155 - Clay Tiffany's Final Days
Clay Tiffany, a notable figure from Briarcliff Manor, NY, leveraged his platform "Dirge for the Charlatans" to critique local authorities, sparking controversy and evoking mixed reactions. His uncompromising stance against perceived injustices made him a polarizing figure, with a legacy deeply rooted in community activism and journalism. Yet, beneath his public persona, hints of tragedy loomed,...
38m Mar 31, 2024
38m
#154 - Let's Find These Missing People (with Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna)
Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna, hosts of the "Crawlspace" and "Missing" podcasts join us on this week's episode. Our old friends catch us up on the case that put them on the map, the cold case of Maura Murray. Then, all four of us spend a few minutes highlighting some missing people that we want to bring to the table including Riley Strain, Brianna Maitland, Terrence Woods Jr., and Oakley Ca...
1hr 18m Mar 24, 2024
1hr 18m
NMR #61 - Daryn's Gym Nightmares Continue
This Daryn-heavy episode features EVEN MORE inappropriate weirdos at the gym! SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! (http://youtube.com/@shakenanddisturbed) Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on Patreon! Patreon members can join us during our live recordings, comment on the case, participate in polls and get shout outs! Join for as little as $5 a month...
37m Mar 21, 2024
37m
The Doppelganger Murder (Flashback)
We're taking a week off while John recovers from being sick! So here's an episode from about a year ago. When beauty influencer Khadija O. is approached to do a brand deal with one of her favorite musical artists, she can't help but jump at the idea. What she doesn't know is that the person approaching her is out for blood. This episode originally aired in April 2023. SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND ...
40m Mar 17, 2024
40m
#153 - House of Justice
This is the true crime story of the perplexing disappearance of Carolyn Muncey from her home in Luttrell, Tennessee, on July 13th, 1985. As Carolyn vanished, leaving her two young children and husband Hubert behind, the small town of less than 1,000 people was thrust into a state of unease. With Carolyn's body discovered in a shocking location, the investigation intensified, revealing disturbin...
32m Mar 10, 2024
32m
NMR #60 - Schnooking A Schnookus
Instagram is listening to our every word and John has a disturbing example. Daryn is left shaken after an emergency with a friend's cat! SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! (http://youtube.com/@shakenanddisturbed) Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on Patreon! Patreon members can join us during our live recordings, comment on the case, participate in...
40m Mar 07, 2024
40m
#152 - The Cockeyed Cook
In this episode delve into the harrowing tale of Billy Cook, a troubled young man whose life spiraled into darkness after a tragic childhood. From his turbulent upbringing to a series of violent crimes that culminated in a horrific killing spree, follow the haunting journey of a man known as 'Cockeyed Cook'. As authorities race against time to apprehend him, you'll be gripped by the unfolding t...
42m Mar 03, 2024
42m
#151 - The Killer On Camera
When Deidre Hunt and Konstantinos 'Kosta' Fotopoulos begin their relationship, they can't possibly comprehend how it's going to end. As their tumultuous relationship unfolds they're drawn into a world of deceit, where armed robbery and counterfeiting are just the beginning. Shockingly, a murder is captured on film, revealing the depths of darkness hidden beneath the facade of an ordinary couple...
37m Feb 25, 2024
37m
NMR #59 - What's That Thing That Blows Leaves?
John has a hard time remembering what a leaf blower is. Daryn's Mom Zooie makes her long-awaited podcast debut! SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! (http://youtube.com/@shakenanddisturbed) Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on Patreon! Patreon members can join us during our live recordings, comment on the case, participate in polls and get shout outs...
37m Feb 22, 2024
37m
#150 - False Teeth, False Justice
In 1982, Keith Harward's life took a tragic turn following the brutal murder of Jesse Perron and the assault on his wife Teresa in Newport News, Virginia. Despite compelling evidence pointing elsewhere, Keith faced a flawed legal system that relied on outdated forensic methods like bite mark analysis to secure his conviction. SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! (http://youtube.com/@s...
40m Feb 18, 2024
40m