INTRO: Welcome to the NSPCC Learning podcast, where
INTRO: we share learning and expertise in child protection
INTRO: from inside and outside of the organisation.
INTRO: We aim to create debate, encourage reflection and
INTRO: share good practice on how we can all work together
INTRO: to keep babies, children and young people safe.
JULIAN FABIAN: A very warm welcome to the NSPCC Learning
JULIAN FABIAN: podcast.
JULIAN FABIAN: I'm Julian Fabian, consultant social worker
JULIAN FABIAN: in the NSPCC's Quality and Practice team,
JULIAN FABIAN: and for this episode I'm joined by two
JULIAN FABIAN: colleagues, Emily and Damian, to explore the
JULIAN FABIAN: subject of voice of the child in social work
JULIAN FABIAN: practice.
JULIAN FABIAN: So Emily and Damian, why don't you introduce
JULIAN FABIAN: yourselves and tell the listeners a little
JULIAN FABIAN: bit about yourselves, and then we'll dive
JULIAN FABIAN: into today's subject.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: Hi, my name's Damien Fitzpatrick and
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: I'm a consultant social worker based in
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: the Quality and Practice team.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: I've worked for the NSPCC now for about
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: ten years. Before that I was a local
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: authority social worker.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: Our main role in the Quality and Practice
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: team is practice development and
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: quality assurance.
EMILY WADDINGTON: Hi, my name's Emily Waddington and I
EMILY WADDINGTON: currently work in Childline.
EMILY WADDINGTON: I've been a qualified social worker since
EMILY WADDINGTON: 2019, and I've worked in the local
EMILY WADDINGTON: authority and in the charity sector.
EMILY WADDINGTON: I've always been interested in the voice
EMILY WADDINGTON: of the child, and previously I've had
EMILY WADDINGTON: some work that I've done on the voice of
EMILY WADDINGTON: the infant be presented at the World
EMILY WADDINGTON: Infant Mental Health Conference.
JULIAN FABIAN: Thanks for that. Lovely to have you with me
JULIAN FABIAN: today. So I thought it'd be really helpful
JULIAN FABIAN: to start off our discussion by building a
JULIAN FABIAN: strong and clear foundation, and
JULIAN FABIAN: really be interested in what you think we
JULIAN FABIAN: mean by the voice of the child.
EMILY WADDINGTON: So I think, for me, the voice of the
EMILY WADDINGTON: child is about thinking about the young
EMILY WADDINGTON: person's experiences, their worries and
EMILY WADDINGTON: their wants.
EMILY WADDINGTON: And there's a whole host of different
EMILY WADDINGTON: ways we can hear and understand the young
EMILY WADDINGTON: person's voice. And really, what we mean
EMILY WADDINGTON: about the young person's voice and why it
EMILY WADDINGTON: becomes so useful is because once we've
EMILY WADDINGTON: got that voice of the young person, it
EMILY WADDINGTON: means the professionals can start acting
EMILY WADDINGTON: in the child's best interest.
JULIAN FABIAN: That's a good place to start.
JULIAN FABIAN: One of the things I'm interested in is why
JULIAN FABIAN: we believe the voice of the child is so
JULIAN FABIAN: important to social work practice.
EMILY WADDINGTON: Children and family social work exists
EMILY WADDINGTON: to safeguard and promote the welfare of
EMILY WADDINGTON: young people and children, and we simply
EMILY WADDINGTON: can't do that without an understanding
EMILY WADDINGTON: of the voice of the child.
EMILY WADDINGTON: So we need that understanding of their
EMILY WADDINGTON: experiences, their worries and their
EMILY WADDINGTON: wants in order for us to do our job, in
EMILY WADDINGTON: order to safeguard them and to promote
EMILY WADDINGTON: their welfare.
EMILY WADDINGTON: If we try to do that without hearing the
EMILY WADDINGTON: voice of the child, we risk practising in
EMILY WADDINGTON: a way that's really oppressive.
EMILY WADDINGTON: It's important that young people are able
EMILY WADDINGTON: to take part in the decisions that we're
EMILY WADDINGTON: making about them and that are in their
EMILY WADDINGTON: interest.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: Yeah, I think the voice of the child is
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: central really to what we do in our
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: daily practice and working with
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: children. We want to promote best
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: outcomes for children, and the best way
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: to do that is to hear what the children
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: want and hear how to
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: best engage that child in any
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: intervention, promote engagement and
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: work towards...
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: Work jointly, I suppose, with the child
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: and the family in collaborating towards
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: good outcomes for the child.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: So it's all about collaboration,
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: engagement and the child's view and
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: wishes and feelings, I think.
EMILY WADDINGTON: Damien, just to jump in, that's such a
EMILY WADDINGTON: good point, isn't it? We don't want to
EMILY WADDINGTON: 'do' to families or to young people.
EMILY WADDINGTON: We absolutely want to work together.
EMILY WADDINGTON: And yeah, we can't do that without the
EMILY WADDINGTON: child's voice.
JULIAN FABIAN: Absolutely, yeah. So there's something about
JULIAN FABIAN: engaging children, collaborating with
JULIAN FABIAN: children, trying to move away from anything
JULIAN FABIAN: that would become oppressive or be
JULIAN FABIAN: oppressive. It makes me wonder about what
JULIAN FABIAN: barriers there might be to capturing the
JULIAN FABIAN: voice of a child, or what things might get
JULIAN FABIAN: in the way of that in social
JULIAN FABIAN: work practice, and how we might address
JULIAN FABIAN: those or overcome those.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: Quite a few barriers spring to mind,
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: you know. You can have, almost like
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: disguised compliance within families —
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: not even disguised compliance, but not
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: consenting for a worker to actually
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: speak to a child, to speak to a child
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: alone, whether there's a safeguarding
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: issue or a child protection issue.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: So that could be one barrier:
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: non-compliance and non-consent.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: Other barriers could be the type of
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: communication. There could be a
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: learning disability of the child.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: It could be a non-speaking child.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: It could be a child that communicates
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: through alternative means.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: Age — age appropriateness,
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: how to communicate with the child.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: I suppose it's important to have a
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: varied degree of skill levels in how to
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: communicate in an age appropriate way
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: with a child. Yeah. So quite a few
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: barriers can spring up in the day-to-day
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: practice of a social worker really, I
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: would say.
EMILY WADDINGTON: Yeah, Damien, I think you make a really
EMILY WADDINGTON: good point about, you know, for example,
EMILY WADDINGTON: a child who's not verbal or wants to
EMILY WADDINGTON: communicate in different ways.
EMILY WADDINGTON: Because sometimes I think one of the
EMILY WADDINGTON: barriers to capturing the child's voice
EMILY WADDINGTON: is that social workers can be overreliant
EMILY WADDINGTON: on the verbal voice only. So social
EMILY WADDINGTON: workers might not be looking at
EMILY WADDINGTON: behaviours, body language, facial
EMILY WADDINGTON: expressions.
EMILY WADDINGTON: There's something about being open to the
EMILY WADDINGTON: different ways we can get the child's
EMILY WADDINGTON: voice.
EMILY WADDINGTON: Some of the other things in terms of
EMILY WADDINGTON: barriers, one that's probably very
EMILY WADDINGTON: familiar to lots of social workers, is
EMILY WADDINGTON: feeling like you might not have enough
EMILY WADDINGTON: time to build the kind of relationship
EMILY WADDINGTON: you want to build with the young person.
EMILY WADDINGTON: If we can build meaningful relationships
EMILY WADDINGTON: with young people, I think it's going to
EMILY WADDINGTON: be a lot easier for us to get and hear
EMILY WADDINGTON: the voice of the young person.
EMILY WADDINGTON: And another barrier sometimes is that, on
EMILY WADDINGTON: a human level, I think sometimes
EMILY WADDINGTON: professionals can struggle to understand
EMILY WADDINGTON: that abuse is going on.
EMILY WADDINGTON: It's a difficult and unpleasant thing to
EMILY WADDINGTON: think about, so professionals have to
EMILY WADDINGTON: work really hard to make sure we're open
EMILY WADDINGTON: to hearing what the child has got to say,
EMILY WADDINGTON: to trusting it and really placing value
EMILY WADDINGTON: in it, as well.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: Absolutely, Emily. Just to jump in
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: there, you make an excellent point
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: about the time, you know, and I think
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: the relationship building, building
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: that rapport. And even if you do have
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: time, I think in particularly complex
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: cases, whether it's sexual abuse cases,
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: it could take a lot of relationship
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: building and trust building for a child
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: to feel safe to open up
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: and to really hear that child's voice.
JULIAN FABIAN: Okay, so a range of things that might get in
JULIAN FABIAN: the way of us hearing the voice of the
JULIAN FABIAN: child, whether it's a disability or some
JULIAN FABIAN: medical barrier, whether it's time
JULIAN FABIAN: constraints, whether it's parents or
JULIAN FABIAN: carers having a worry in terms of allowing
JULIAN FABIAN: access to the child, whether it's a child
JULIAN FABIAN: having a worry. So a range of things that
JULIAN FABIAN: maybe need a range of solutions and we can
JULIAN FABIAN: come on to talk about those in a minute.
JULIAN FABIAN: One of the things I noticed you talked about
JULIAN FABIAN: was about children speaking, or
JULIAN FABIAN: being pre-speaking or non-speaking.
JULIAN FABIAN: I think the previous language we used was
JULIAN FABIAN: pre-verbal, verbal and non-verbal.
JULIAN FABIAN: So I'm interested if you could talk a little
JULIAN FABIAN: bit about the the rationale for the change
JULIAN FABIAN: in language and why that might be helpful.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: The language has quite correctly
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: changed because a lot of children who
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: are who would have been considered
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: non-verbal now can communicate and
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: actually verbalise their feelings
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: through other means, really, so they
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: can speak.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: For instance, I suppose a good example
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: of this would be, augmentative
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: communication, where some disabled
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: children, for instance, would use high
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: tech devices to communicate.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: There's also things like communication books,
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: simple communication, right down
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: to your kind of your simple makaton,
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: stuff like that. So I think we've made
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: a lot of advances.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: So we've moved on and quite rightly,
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: the terminology has moved on along with
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: that.
JULIAN FABIAN: So we want to move away from language that
JULIAN FABIAN: might potentially be stigmatising or exclude
JULIAN FABIAN: children.
EMILY WADDINGTON: Yeah. And I think that helps
EMILY WADDINGTON: professionals to be a bit more open as
EMILY WADDINGTON: well, doesn't it? Because we're not just
EMILY WADDINGTON: thinking about the verbal communication.
EMILY WADDINGTON: When we change the language, as
EMILY WADDINGTON: professionals you become more open to
EMILY WADDINGTON: seeing many other forms of communication,
EMILY WADDINGTON: which is totally necessary to help us
EMILY WADDINGTON: gather as much information from as many
EMILY WADDINGTON: different means as possible about, you
EMILY WADDINGTON: know, the voice of the young person, to
EMILY WADDINGTON: really help us understand.
JULIAN FABIAN: It's thinking that if we get our language
JULIAN FABIAN: right, we get our thinking right.
JULIAN FABIAN: If we get our thinking right, that affects
JULIAN FABIAN: our practice in terms of improving outcomes
JULIAN FABIAN: for children.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: And I suppose that adds to the point
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: where communication is not just
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: language and speaking, you know.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: It's behaviour.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: Just what's sprung to my mind, it's why
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: observations of behaviour are perhaps
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: key and so important in communication.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: Just observing the interactions,
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: the behaviour of the child, how they
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: feel, how they interact with perhaps an
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: adult, the adults around them, how they
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: interact in different environments, how
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: they interact in a school setting or
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: a home setting, or while
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: in dad's care as opposed to while in
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: mum's care, and what those environmental
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: behaviours are telling us about a
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: child's communication and their wishes
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: and feelings.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: How do they inform us as our social
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: workers? How do they inform our
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: assessment? How do they inform our work
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: plan going forward, and how we conduct
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: our intervention and how we engage that
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: child moving forward as our work
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: progresses?
EMILY WADDINGTON: Yeah. Damien, I think you're totally
EMILY WADDINGTON: right and there's so many valid points in
EMILY WADDINGTON: there. One thing that I really love and
EMILY WADDINGTON: think is so important about considering
EMILY WADDINGTON: other forms of communication outside of
EMILY WADDINGTON: speaking, is it's something about perhaps
EMILY WADDINGTON: taking off the pressure and
EMILY WADDINGTON: responsibility of a young person to say
EMILY WADDINGTON: something out loud which can just feel so
EMILY WADDINGTON: incredibly scary.
EMILY WADDINGTON: Quite often we might have young people
EMILY WADDINGTON: who are being abused who feel a sense of
EMILY WADDINGTON: loyalty towards the person who is
EMILY WADDINGTON: perpetrating the abuse.
EMILY WADDINGTON: And if we can be open to seeing and
EMILY WADDINGTON: hearing other forms of communication, we
EMILY WADDINGTON: can almost take some pressure or
EMILY WADDINGTON: responsibility of that young person.
EMILY WADDINGTON: So it's not, "why didn't you tell us?"
EMILY WADDINGTON: It's "why didn't we look?
EMILY WADDINGTON: How can we see more what you're trying to
EMILY WADDINGTON: tell us?" And I think that's so
EMILY WADDINGTON: important.
JULIAN FABIAN: It feels we're now moving on, having laid
JULIAN FABIAN: the foundations of what the voice of the
JULIAN FABIAN: child is and why it's important and how we
JULIAN FABIAN: talk about children and the voice of child,
JULIAN FABIAN: to thinking about what that looks like in
JULIAN FABIAN: practice. I'm interested in, if I saw
JULIAN FABIAN: you 'doing' the voice of child in social
JULIAN FABIAN: work practice, what might that look like
JULIAN FABIAN: practically?
EMILY WADDINGTON: So I used to work in a team where we
EMILY WADDINGTON: would have...
EMILY WADDINGTON: If there was a professionals meeting, so
EMILY WADDINGTON: if it was a case of families and young
EMILY WADDINGTON: people not being invited to that meeting,
EMILY WADDINGTON: we would have a professional act as the
EMILY WADDINGTON: voice of the child in that meeting.
EMILY WADDINGTON: And that was so powerful.
EMILY WADDINGTON: Everyone would go around and give their
EMILY WADDINGTON: updates and their professional opinion,
EMILY WADDINGTON: and then the person who was acting as the
EMILY WADDINGTON: voice of the child would give a summary,
EMILY WADDINGTON: talk about how they think that might have
EMILY WADDINGTON: felt for the young person, what they
EMILY WADDINGTON: might need, what their experiences are.
EMILY WADDINGTON: And this was so powerful.
EMILY WADDINGTON: It meant the voice of the young person
EMILY WADDINGTON: had the same amount of time, the same
EMILY WADDINGTON: weight, the same value as what everyone
EMILY WADDINGTON: else was saying in the meeting.
EMILY WADDINGTON: But also for me personally, when I was in
EMILY WADDINGTON: that role, I found it very emotional,
EMILY WADDINGTON: sometimes quite draining, and that was
EMILY WADDINGTON: also such useful information as well.
EMILY WADDINGTON: It helped me to maybe understand the
EMILY WADDINGTON: young person I was working with a bit
EMILY WADDINGTON: more, try to put them in context,
EMILY WADDINGTON: increased empathy, increased
EMILY WADDINGTON: understanding for them.
EMILY WADDINGTON: That's something I've done in meetings
EMILY WADDINGTON: before, and I found to be really, really
EMILY WADDINGTON: powerful and really useful.
JULIAN FABIAN: So there's something about how that helped
JULIAN FABIAN: to keep the voice of the child or
JULIAN FABIAN: their lived experience, their world, front
JULIAN FABIAN: and centre to your thinking, and your
JULIAN FABIAN: assessment and your intervention.
EMILY WADDINGTON: Absolutely. And I think it's also
EMILY WADDINGTON: important just to add in that where we've
EMILY WADDINGTON: got meetings with the young person and
EMILY WADDINGTON: the family there we want to give them
EMILY WADDINGTON: that space. Maybe prepare them in advance
EMILY WADDINGTON: about what they might want to say, but
EMILY WADDINGTON: making sure where there's those meetings
EMILY WADDINGTON: where the young person can't be present,
EMILY WADDINGTON: that we're still giving them space, room
EMILY WADDINGTON: and real validity in those meetings.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: I agree. It's very much about treating
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: the child like they're an expert in
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: their own life, really, and about
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: including them in all of the work,
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: whether it is your assessments,
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: your work plans, your desired outcomes,
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: and at every point in your
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: intervention, perhaps getting the
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: child's views on that piece of work.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: As a consultant social worker reviewing
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: casework, some of the most impressive
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: cases are those where the practitioner
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: will actually sit with the child, go
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: through their assessment point-by-point,
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: and get the child's views about that
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: point, whether it's a risk or whether
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: it's a desired outcome.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: And all of that can be directly linked
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: to the work plan then.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: Any of the cases that I would deem
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: outstanding will have that voice of the
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: child element in them from the
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: beginning of the case right towards the
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: end. And at every junction of the case
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: where the child is actually, kind of,
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: almost consulted and collaborated in
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: all of the work, and can actually
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: direct the work to an extent to
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: meet a need that they've identified
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: themselves. As I say, treating the
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: child like an expert in their own
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: lives, you know.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: What I would say practically too, in
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: casework, because of what we've just
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: said — about the many barriers, for
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: instance, the many types of
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: communication — is it's always good to
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: consult a fellow professional, whether
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: it's a speech and language expert or a
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: teacher at school or someone else that
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: will have a greater degree of
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: knowledge in how to best communicate
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: with that child or a parent.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: So taking on board that and learning
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: new skills as you go along in your
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: work. So an almost, kind of. Reflection
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: and action aspect about it.
EMILY WADDINGTON: I love how you describe that.
EMILY WADDINGTON: That's so, I think, humble from a
EMILY WADDINGTON: professional point of view.
EMILY WADDINGTON: So you're going in to see this young
EMILY WADDINGTON: person. Who else knows this young person?
EMILY WADDINGTON: How can they help you build a
EMILY WADDINGTON: relationship with them, which is great,
EMILY WADDINGTON: but also about them being the expert in
EMILY WADDINGTON: their own lives? I think that comes
EMILY WADDINGTON: through so strongly in how you talk,
EMILY WADDINGTON: Damien, but especially when we're
EMILY WADDINGTON: thinking about about the voice of the child,
EMILY WADDINGTON: it's always got to be about that
EMILY WADDINGTON: collaboration and that informing the work
EMILY WADDINGTON: that we do, rather than is excluding the
EMILY WADDINGTON: child from this completely thinking we
EMILY WADDINGTON: know best, which is much more damaging,
EMILY WADDINGTON: unhelpful and ultimately ineffective.
EMILY WADDINGTON: I think it's how I've described it.
EMILY WADDINGTON: It's really helpful.
JULIAN FABIAN: So where you as a social worker aren't able
JULIAN FABIAN: to sit in the room with a child — because I
JULIAN FABIAN: think the example you gave Damien was really
JULIAN FABIAN: helpful about the the worker sitting in the
JULIAN FABIAN: room with the child and speaking to him and
JULIAN FABIAN: listening to him. Where that's physically
JULIAN FABIAN: not possible, what might capturing the voice
JULIAN FABIAN: of the child look like in social work
JULIAN FABIAN: practice?
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: For me, observation is key.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: What immediately would spring to mind
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: is perhaps an unborn child, if you're
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: working with a pregnant mum, for
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: instance. So a lot of observation about
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: the preparation for the unborn child,
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: the level of support of both parents
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: and how they talk about the unborn
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: child. So all are indicators.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: You can indicate what would be safe for
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: this child, what is good for this child
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: and what this child wants. Ultimately
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: what the... If we're talking about an
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: unborn child, they want to arrive into
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: a safe, secure and happy environment,
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: you know. And a lot of your
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: observations, as a practitioner,
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: you will have a fair amount of
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: indicators of that, that you can then
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: build into your analysis to paint a
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: picture.
EMILY WADDINGTON: Yeah, I think for me it's about getting
EMILY WADDINGTON: those observations where you can.
EMILY WADDINGTON: And also I think trying to offer
EMILY WADDINGTON: different means of communication, like if
EMILY WADDINGTON: you can't be there in person talking
EMILY WADDINGTON: to the young person. I've had young
EMILY WADDINGTON: people who might find video calls maybe a
EMILY WADDINGTON: bit overwhelming or a bit frightening.
EMILY WADDINGTON: So they prefer a voice call, or they
EMILY WADDINGTON: might prefer to even text sometimes —
EMILY WADDINGTON: which is, I think can be limiting in
EMILY WADDINGTON: terms of what we can get. But there's
EMILY WADDINGTON: something about having a conversation
EMILY WADDINGTON: with that young person about what is the
EMILY WADDINGTON: best way for us to communicate with you.
EMILY WADDINGTON: I really want to hear what's going on for
EMILY WADDINGTON: you, what feels easiest and
EMILY WADDINGTON: and most helpful and most meaningful to
EMILY WADDINGTON: each young person.
JULIAN FABIAN: Thanks, Emily. That's helpful.
JULIAN FABIAN: The other thing that popped into my head was
JULIAN FABIAN: something that Damien referenced helpfully
JULIAN FABIAN: around biases.
JULIAN FABIAN: And I think some people might say, "well,
JULIAN FABIAN: hang on a minute. I'm a qualified
JULIAN FABIAN: professional social worker.
JULIAN FABIAN: I'm aware of myself as an individual.
JULIAN FABIAN: I don't have any biases or they don't
JULIAN FABIAN: influence me." But I'm interested what
JULIAN FABIAN: the biases we might carry in terms of
JULIAN FABIAN: working with the voice of a child and how we
JULIAN FABIAN: might manage those or attend to those so
JULIAN FABIAN: they don't get in the way.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: I think reflection is the key word, you
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: know. Just reflect on our practice,
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: reflect on our feelings, reflect on our
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: assumptions. Use supervision, I think,
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: to discuss any biases,
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: as we all have them.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: So I think it's about understanding the
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: child's identity, the child's
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: background and factoring into
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: your reflections any biases you will
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: have regarding identity, cultural
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: background, sexuality, any of that.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: And using the supervision process to
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: tease all of that out and reflect on
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: that.
EMILY WADDINGTON: It's something that we actually need to
EMILY WADDINGTON: own, that we do have biases.
EMILY WADDINGTON: Because once we do that, we can engage
EMILY WADDINGTON: much more effectively and honestly in all
EMILY WADDINGTON: the things Damien is talking about.
EMILY WADDINGTON: So once we can say, "do you know what,
EMILY WADDINGTON: this is something that I sometimes trip
EMILY WADDINGTON: up on or a bias that I hold", we
EMILY WADDINGTON: can then take that to supervision and
EMILY WADDINGTON: talk about it in a place that feels safe
EMILY WADDINGTON: and much more constructive.
EMILY WADDINGTON: But yeah, I think for me, reflection has
EMILY WADDINGTON: got to be the most important place to be.
JULIAN FABIAN: Yeah, that's helpful. So there's something
JULIAN FABIAN: about being self-aware, and about working
JULIAN FABIAN: in an environment of high support and high
JULIAN FABIAN: challenge, and to make sure biases are
JULIAN FABIAN: brought to light and managed.
JULIAN FABIAN: So we've referenced, in passing, record
JULIAN FABIAN: keeping. But I wanted to spend a little time
JULIAN FABIAN: thinking about the records we keep, and
JULIAN FABIAN: particularly what the voice of a child might
JULIAN FABIAN: look like in good record keeping, but also
JULIAN FABIAN: why that's important.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: I think record keeping is extremely
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: important. What springs to mind is
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: perhaps a child brought up in the care
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: system, or a looked after child, who
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: request their records.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: What you've got to think as a child
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: care professional, as a social worker,
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: is what will these records tell this
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: child? What are they going to look like
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: when the child requests these records
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: and looks back and wants to know about
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: their life and their identity and the
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: really, really, really crucial and
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: important decisions that have impacted
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: on their life.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: I think the records need to be
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: accurate. The language needs to be
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: thought about. They need to be quite
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: transparent towards the child.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: And I think that's why things like the
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: voice of the child needs to be threaded
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: throughout our records so that the
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: child can see on a page
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: their life, you know. What they've
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: contributed to their life, how their
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: wishes and feelings were respected, how
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: decisions were made with them included
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: in the decision-making process.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: And the rationale is built into the
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: records that any decisions that were
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: made were made in the child's best
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: interests, and that is evident when
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: they're reading them retrospectively.
EMILY WADDINGTON: The other things that I would add in
EMILY WADDINGTON: terms of recording, and making sure we
EMILY WADDINGTON: are getting the voice of the child in
EMILY WADDINGTON: recording, is having prompts.
EMILY WADDINGTON: I find prompts on systems useful to talk
EMILY WADDINGTON: about — what did you observe —
EMILY WADDINGTON: as a little reminder that we're expanding
EMILY WADDINGTON: out beyond what has a child said.
EMILY WADDINGTON: What have we seen?
EMILY WADDINGTON: What have we observed? What do we think
EMILY WADDINGTON: that means? So I think having those
EMILY WADDINGTON: prompts feels really useful.
EMILY WADDINGTON: Again, we're talking about young people
EMILY WADDINGTON: accessing records, which is so important.
EMILY WADDINGTON: We hold so much information that is
EMILY WADDINGTON: really sensitive, intimate, personal
EMILY WADDINGTON: to that young person.
EMILY WADDINGTON: So we really need to be showing that
EMILY WADDINGTON: we've made every effort to that young
EMILY WADDINGTON: person to really understand what was
EMILY WADDINGTON: going on for them, and to really show how
EMILY WADDINGTON: hard we have tried to make things happen
EMILY WADDINGTON: in their best interests.
EMILY WADDINGTON: And again, just going back to the bit
EMILY WADDINGTON: about observations, there is something
EMILY WADDINGTON: for me about writing in a way that makes
EMILY WADDINGTON: sure we don't, again, place that burden
EMILY WADDINGTON: or responsibility on the young person to
EMILY WADDINGTON: tell us everything. Tell us about, you
EMILY WADDINGTON: know, these scary things that are
EMILY WADDINGTON: happening. And we need to be really
EMILY WADDINGTON: careful when we're wording that in our
EMILY WADDINGTON: recording. So it's not that just because
EMILY WADDINGTON: the child hasn't said something doesn't
EMILY WADDINGTON: necessarily mean that everything is fine.
EMILY WADDINGTON: Our openness to other forms of communication
EMILY WADDINGTON: and reflecting that in recording really
EMILY WADDINGTON: shows we're working with the young
EMILY WADDINGTON: person, and I think reduces
EMILY WADDINGTON: responsibility and pressure on them to
EMILY WADDINGTON: have been the ones who are keeping
EMILY WADDINGTON: themselves safe. When, actually, that's
EMILY WADDINGTON: the job of professionals and parents and
EMILY WADDINGTON: families.
JULIAN FABIAN: There is something important also by
JULIAN FABIAN: the sounds of it about capturing exactly
JULIAN FABIAN: what children say on their records, using
JULIAN FABIAN: their actual words.
JULIAN FABIAN: And then when we make the jump between what
JULIAN FABIAN: they say and what that might mean, and being
JULIAN FABIAN: aware of our biases in terms of how we
JULIAN FABIAN: interpret that and therefore what we do
JULIAN FABIAN: about that. The other thing I'm interested
JULIAN FABIAN: in is, going back to the issue of
JULIAN FABIAN: assessments, why the voice of the child is
JULIAN FABIAN: so important to assessments.
JULIAN FABIAN: Or, another way, what's the impact of having
JULIAN FABIAN: the child's voice central to your
JULIAN FABIAN: assessment?
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: I think it's really, really important
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: in terms of... Depending what the
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: assessment or the focus of the
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: assessment is. Speaking to the child
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: alone, I think is a crucial element to
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: any assessment so that you can kind of
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: ascertain their wishes and feelings
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: about a particular subject.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: Very much a child will get to the nib
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: of a problem and give you their interpretation
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: of it, you know. I suppose what's key,
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: what is a key issue, it's really
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: important what questions you ask the
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: child as well.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: So what are you asking them, and what
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: are you asking of them, and what's your
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: observation of their response can
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: inform your assessment in great detail
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: and ultimately lead to a clearer
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: outcome.
JULIAN FABIAN: So there's something about perhaps the
JULIAN FABIAN: language you use when we ask questions of
JULIAN FABIAN: children, so it's clear and understandable
JULIAN FABIAN: and accessible.
JULIAN FABIAN: But also perhaps there's something about
JULIAN FABIAN: ensuring we're not leading them somewhere
JULIAN FABIAN: they may not want to go.
JULIAN FABIAN: So, not providing them with questions that
JULIAN FABIAN: almost assume the outcome, assume the
JULIAN FABIAN: answer. So we're being as clear and
JULIAN FABIAN: transparent and open to their voice
JULIAN FABIAN: as possible.
EMILY WADDINGTON: I do sometimes think where it feels age
EMILY WADDINGTON: appropriate, there's something about
EMILY WADDINGTON: context as well.
EMILY WADDINGTON: I've worked with young people who have
EMILY WADDINGTON: said, you know, "last time I said
EMILY WADDINGTON: something to a social worker, they took
EMILY WADDINGTON: it out of context and they wrote it down,
EMILY WADDINGTON: and all these things happened that
EMILY WADDINGTON: suddenly felt out of control, or I wasn't
EMILY WADDINGTON: being heard or listened to." So I do
EMILY WADDINGTON: think where it's age appropriate.
EMILY WADDINGTON: We can talk to young people about, you
EMILY WADDINGTON: know, the context and maybe sometimes why
EMILY WADDINGTON: we're asking those questions, what we're
EMILY WADDINGTON: looking to learn and how it might inform
EMILY WADDINGTON: how we try to help or support the family.
EMILY WADDINGTON: And then, in terms of the importance of a
EMILY WADDINGTON: child's voice in an assessment, I don't
EMILY WADDINGTON: think we can get an assessment right
EMILY WADDINGTON: without the child's voice.
EMILY WADDINGTON: Everything that Damien said about a child
EMILY WADDINGTON: being an expert in their own world, we
EMILY WADDINGTON: can't understand their experience, their
EMILY WADDINGTON: wants, their wishes without the child's
EMILY WADDINGTON: voice. And then if we get the child's
EMILY WADDINGTON: voice and we listen to it, I think we
EMILY WADDINGTON: really increase the likelihood that we
EMILY WADDINGTON: can create positive change for a young
EMILY WADDINGTON: person and their family.
EMILY WADDINGTON: You know, are we offering intervention
EMILY WADDINGTON: that meets the child's or young person's
EMILY WADDINGTON: needs? Is it what they want to happen?
EMILY WADDINGTON: And also does it offer validity?
EMILY WADDINGTON: Sometimes there might be disagreement
EMILY WADDINGTON: about what a young person needs or about
EMILY WADDINGTON: what intervention would be useful.
EMILY WADDINGTON: But actually, if we can say, you know,
EMILY WADDINGTON: this is what we think the young person
EMILY WADDINGTON: wants based on what we've seen, what
EMILY WADDINGTON: we've heard, what we've observed, I think
EMILY WADDINGTON: it really makes the whole assessment more robust
EMILY WADDINGTON: when we've got and the person's voice
EMILY WADDINGTON: running all the way through it.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: Just to jump on that a little bit,
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: Emily, is the demonstrating
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: to the child, kind of, you said, we
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: did. "You said this, this is the
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: outcome of our assessment, you know,
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: which was directly influenced by you."
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: So I suppose promoting that trustful
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: relationship, you know. This was your
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: voice. This was the impact of your
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: voice. And this is the outcome of my
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: assessment. And it's quite evident that
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: you're a very, very important person in
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: this assessment process, and you have
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: influenced it.
EMILY WADDINGTON: Absolutely.
EMILY WADDINGTON: The assessment is the first part of the
EMILY WADDINGTON: relationship with the young person.
EMILY WADDINGTON: And if we can build trust and show their
EMILY WADDINGTON: importance there, that really sets the
EMILY WADDINGTON: scene.
JULIAN FABIAN: And practically, thinking about how we close
JULIAN FABIAN: the loop, that can include: we ask questions
JULIAN FABIAN: of them or we have a discussion; they give
JULIAN FABIAN: some feedback; and then there's how we share
JULIAN FABIAN: our information with them to check is fair
JULIAN FABIAN: and accurate, to check we haven't been
JULIAN FABIAN: influenced by our biases, to engage and
JULIAN FABIAN: empower the young person that they feel part
JULIAN FABIAN: of the process and that it's representative.
JULIAN FABIAN: So we close the loop in terms of capturing
JULIAN FABIAN: the voice of the child accurately.
JULIAN FABIAN: So finally, what I would like to ask the
JULIAN FABIAN: both of you is: what's the one key takeaway
JULIAN FABIAN: you'd want to leave listeners with in terms
JULIAN FABIAN: of the voice of the child in social work
JULIAN FABIAN: practice?
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: Mine would be not to get caught up on
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: adult issues. You know, we do have
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: biases. We do have relationships with
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: adults. We have all of these various
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: pressures in work and families.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: And I think my one key takeaway would
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: be go straight to the heart of the
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: matter and go straight to the child,
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: and there is a font of knowledge
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: waiting right there in your level of
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: communication with the child. As we've
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: discussed earlier, that child might
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: be non-speaking, there could be
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: learning disability, but there's ways
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: around that and there's ways to capture
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: the child's wishes and feelings.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: So go straight to the child I would say
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: would be my one take away.
EMILY WADDINGTON: Oh, I just so want to squeeze two in.
JULIAN FABIAN: I can allow you two.
EMILY WADDINGTON: Very generous, thank you.
EMILY WADDINGTON: So my first one is to remember that the
EMILY WADDINGTON: voice of the child is more than just
EMILY WADDINGTON: speaking.
EMILY WADDINGTON: Please look. Please observe.
EMILY WADDINGTON: Write down what you see, think about what
EMILY WADDINGTON: it might mean, and consider that together
EMILY WADDINGTON: with something speaking, if that's
EMILY WADDINGTON: available to you.
EMILY WADDINGTON: And then my second point is just to
EMILY WADDINGTON: borrow from Damien, which is that the
EMILY WADDINGTON: child is the expert in their own world.
EMILY WADDINGTON: I think if you use that as a guiding
EMILY WADDINGTON: principle, you are going to work really
EMILY WADDINGTON: hard to capture the voice of the child in
EMILY WADDINGTON: a really meaningful way for the rest of
EMILY WADDINGTON: your work as well.
JULIAN FABIAN: Great. Thanks Damien and Emily.
JULIAN FABIAN: It's been really good to have you with me
JULIAN FABIAN: today to explore the key issue of voice
JULIAN FABIAN: of the child in social work practice.
JULIAN FABIAN: I think it will be really helpful to our
JULIAN FABIAN: audience. So thanks for being with us.
DAMIEN FITZPATRICK: Thank you very much, Julian.
EMILY WADDINGTON: Thanks, Julian. Thanks, Damien.
OUTRO: Thanks for listening to this NSPCC Learning podcast.
OUTRO: At the time of recording, this episode's content was
OUTRO: up to date, but the world of safeguarding and child
OUTRO: protection is ever changing.
OUTRO: So if you're looking for the most current
OUTRO: safeguarding and child protection training,
OUTRO: information or resources, please visit
OUTRO: our website for professionals at
OUTRO: nspcc.org.uk/learning.
We recommend upgrading to the latest Chrome, Firefox, Safari, or Edge.
Please check your internet connection and refresh the page. You might also try disabling any ad blockers.
You can visit our support center if you're having problems.