Audioboom

{"flashNotices":[],"request_id":"51a41883ee1638afa36168d8714d6d22"}

Transcript for The Case of Nicole Dawn Markley

00:00:00,000 → 00:00:05,680

Mountain State Mysteries contains a doc content that may not be suitable for all audiences.

00:00:05,680 → 00:00:08,080

Listener discretion is advised.

00:00:08,080 → 00:00:09,200

I'm your host Mark.

00:00:09,200 → 00:00:10,400

And I'm Courtney.

00:00:10,400 → 00:00:40,240

And this is Mountain State Mysteries.

00:00:40,400 → 00:00:54,320

The case we have for you today is about a girl who had her whole life ahead of her.

00:00:54,320 → 00:00:58,800

This is the story of Nicole Don Markely.

00:00:58,800 → 00:01:05,760

Nicole was last seen by her family on January 17, 2003, when she left her home in the four

00:01:05,760 → 00:01:08,180

states area of West Virginia.

00:01:08,180 → 00:01:12,440

She was walking over to her grandmother's house, something that she did often, but

00:01:12,440 → 00:01:14,520

this time it was different.

00:01:14,520 → 00:01:16,960

She didn't make it to her grandmother's house.

00:01:16,960 → 00:01:19,520

Nicole never returned home that evening.

00:01:19,520 → 00:01:23,800

When her mother, Sherry, realized she never got a call from Nicole during the day, she

00:01:23,800 → 00:01:26,000

started to get concerned.

00:01:26,000 → 00:01:31,000

Sherry said in an interview that, quote, she was a good kid and would always check in with

00:01:31,000 → 00:01:32,000

me.

00:01:32,000 → 00:01:36,280

I thought maybe she was with the new guy she was dating, but she wasn't.

00:01:36,280 → 00:01:37,280

End quote.

00:01:37,280 → 00:01:42,520

Sherry told 8line, she had a bad feeling and wasn't taking any chances.

00:01:42,520 → 00:01:47,560

So she called the Marion County Sheriff's Department and reported her missing.

00:01:47,560 → 00:01:52,520

Family and friends immediately started searching the hills in the four states area of Fairmont,

00:01:52,520 → 00:01:59,080

West Virginia, looking in sheds, backyards, ditches and walking through the woods trying

00:01:59,080 → 00:02:00,080

to find Nicole.

00:02:00,080 → 00:02:02,920

But sadly, there was no trace of her.

00:02:02,920 → 00:02:08,400

Sherry Harris, Nicole's cousin said, quote, I remember just all of us being in the back

00:02:08,400 → 00:02:16,560

of trucks, looking for her in ditches up along streets anywhere we could go walking the hills.

00:02:16,560 → 00:02:17,560

End quote.

00:02:17,560 → 00:02:21,760

Nicole's 17th birthday came and gone.

00:02:21,760 → 00:02:26,000

Her family was still searching for the answer of where Nicole was.

00:02:26,000 → 00:02:31,560

Nicole's mother, Sherry told 8line, she'll always remember the day Nicole was born because

00:02:31,560 → 00:02:39,040

it was the aftermath of the fatal space shuttle Challenger disaster on January 28th, 1986.

00:02:39,040 → 00:02:42,080

The search for Nicole never stopped.

00:02:42,080 → 00:02:49,520

About two weeks later, on February 1st, 2003, a hunter found her body laying face down in

00:02:49,520 → 00:02:53,900

the Teberbock Creek in the four states area of Marion County.

00:02:53,900 → 00:02:58,520

The day Nicole's body was found was also marked by another disaster.

00:02:58,520 → 00:03:04,640

It was the day of the space shuttle Columbia explosion that killed all seven crew members.

00:03:04,640 → 00:03:07,880

Sherry said, quote, it's just something I'll never forget.

00:03:07,880 → 00:03:08,880

End quote.

00:03:08,880 → 00:03:15,120

Sheriff Jimmy Rifle was a roadway deputy at the time, but remembers the impact the case

00:03:15,120 → 00:03:16,880

had on the community.

00:03:16,880 → 00:03:21,600

What they initially thought was that Nicole was another runaway juvenile quickly turned

00:03:21,600 → 00:03:23,800

into a homicide investigation.

00:03:23,800 → 00:03:30,120

He told 8line that the medical examiner concluded that Nicole's death was a homicide, which

00:03:30,120 → 00:03:32,960

jumped started the investigation.

00:03:32,960 → 00:03:39,080

12 news reported that the autopsy results revealed her cause of death was drowning.

00:03:39,080 → 00:03:43,800

Deputies were confident that they knew who her murderer was.

00:03:43,800 → 00:03:51,080

Two years later, in July of 2003, 20 year old William Hammond of four states was charged

00:03:51,080 → 00:03:54,520

with the first degree murder in connection with Nicole's death.

00:03:54,520 → 00:04:00,200

Sheriff Rifle did not get into specifics on what led investigators to Hammond or whether

00:04:00,200 → 00:04:02,800

or not the two knew each other.

00:04:02,800 → 00:04:06,960

Five months later, prosecutors dropped the charges against Hammond.

00:04:06,960 → 00:04:14,680

According to NBC affiliate WBOY for Marion County prosecuting attorney Susan Rifle said

00:04:14,680 → 00:04:20,760

in December 2003, quote, we felt the case needed more investigation.

00:04:20,760 → 00:04:25,400

We felt the best thing for the victim and for justice was to dismiss the indictment

00:04:25,400 → 00:04:26,720

without prejudice.

00:04:26,720 → 00:04:30,880

Christine Hall, Nicole's on said, quote, I flipped out.

00:04:30,880 → 00:04:32,200

I can't believe it.

00:04:32,200 → 00:04:37,000

In quote, no further charges have been filed in the case.

00:04:37,000 → 00:04:41,400

Sherry told 8line, quote, it's not fair and it's not right.

00:04:41,400 → 00:04:45,880

The one who took my child's life is out there running around free.

00:04:45,880 → 00:04:47,400

It's not fair for her.

00:04:47,400 → 00:04:49,080

Not fair for her family.

00:04:49,080 → 00:04:50,520

Not fair for her son.

00:04:50,520 → 00:04:56,800

In quote, Detective Kevin Alkir said people in the community of four states are staying

00:04:56,800 → 00:04:57,800

tight leapt.

00:04:57,800 → 00:05:02,880

Quote, I would say probably someone in four states or more than one individual probably

00:05:02,880 → 00:05:09,000

has information about this case and we can just hope one day they will come forward.

00:05:09,000 → 00:05:14,880

In quote, Nicole's son Jeremiah was just one month away from turning two years old when

00:05:14,880 → 00:05:16,160

his mother was killed.

00:05:16,160 → 00:05:18,840

He was raised by Sherry and her husband Jeff.

00:05:18,840 → 00:05:24,560

When he graduated high school in 2020, he said it was in honor of his mother who wasn't

00:05:24,560 → 00:05:27,280

able to graduate before she was killed.

00:05:27,280 → 00:05:30,080

Sherry said, quote, she'd be so proud of him.

00:05:30,080 → 00:05:35,720

In quote, she also said that he's a spitting image of Nicole from her bright smile to her

00:05:35,720 → 00:05:38,200

spunky attitude.

00:05:38,200 → 00:05:45,720

Sherry said, quote, we keep her memory alive for him and for us every holiday, every birthday,

00:05:45,720 → 00:05:47,760

every day of our lives.

00:05:47,760 → 00:05:49,400

We talk about her.

00:05:49,400 → 00:05:55,600

In quote, Nicole's family hopes that keeping her memory alive will feel their never ending

00:05:55,600 → 00:05:57,960

fight for justice.

00:05:57,960 → 00:06:02,960

She believes the person who killed her daughter was infected with her and that the charges

00:06:02,960 → 00:06:05,680

should never have been dropped.

00:06:05,680 → 00:06:10,560

Sherry said, quote, he continues to be free while our family mourns.

00:06:10,560 → 00:06:13,240

It's like a nightmare that never ends.

00:06:13,240 → 00:06:19,920

Share a frightful told Dateline that he understands that the family is frustrated over the lack

00:06:19,920 → 00:06:24,400

of closure and stressed that they haven't given up on her case.

00:06:24,400 → 00:06:30,160

Quote, throughout the years, the investigation slowed down as we exhausted all of our leads

00:06:30,160 → 00:06:32,520

and tips stop coming in.

00:06:32,520 → 00:06:36,720

In quote, share frightful added that the case is cold.

00:06:36,720 → 00:06:39,520

But as detectives, I have time.

00:06:39,520 → 00:06:40,520

They work on it.

00:06:40,520 → 00:06:44,640

For now, Nicole's family visits her memorial.

00:06:44,640 → 00:06:47,960

Sherry said that her daughter's death will always haunt her.

00:06:47,960 → 00:06:53,200

Family members have mixed emotions about whether the case will ever be closed.

00:06:53,200 → 00:06:58,680

For now, they keep her memory alive by sharing her story with the community and online with

00:06:58,680 → 00:07:02,760

the Facebook group in memory and Nicole Don Markely.

00:07:02,760 → 00:07:08,800

Anyone with any information regarding Nicole's case is asked to contact the Marion County

00:07:08,800 → 00:07:18,440

Sheriff's Department at 304-367-5300.

00:07:18,440 → 00:07:21,000

Courtney, do you have any final thoughts on this case?

00:07:21,000 → 00:07:31,320

I just think it's really sad that this case hasn't garnered much attention.

00:07:31,320 → 00:07:38,520

I feel that is sad that the police have failed her.

00:07:38,520 → 00:07:42,080

I think that's the biggest thing.

00:07:42,080 → 00:07:49,560

One of my biggest questions is I wonder if the sheriff and the prosecuting attorney work

00:07:49,560 → 00:07:50,560

in.

00:07:50,560 → 00:07:57,120

I just want to know what led them to think that there was a lack of evidence.

00:07:57,120 → 00:08:02,040

What made them think other things of this nature?

00:08:02,040 → 00:08:07,120

I want to know what else happened to her.

00:08:07,120 → 00:08:19,560

I know people can drown in few inches of water and everything, but it just makes me wonder

00:08:19,560 → 00:08:20,560

how this happened.

00:08:20,560 → 00:08:21,720

Was there anything else?

00:08:21,720 → 00:08:23,920

Was there stuff that they missed?

00:08:23,920 → 00:08:26,960

Things of that nature.

00:08:26,960 → 00:08:32,600

I'm sad that this son never got the chance to really know his mother.

00:08:32,600 → 00:08:39,120

He never got to experience a lot of memories with his mother, but I'm happy that his family

00:08:39,120 → 00:08:43,320

is keeping the memory of her alive for him.

00:08:43,320 → 00:08:46,560

Mark, do you have any final thoughts on this?

00:08:46,560 → 00:08:48,400

Like you, I really hate this case.

00:08:48,400 → 00:08:51,720

It hasn't got the light that it should.

00:08:51,720 → 00:08:57,760

I honestly feel like it could be solved if the pieces were there.

00:08:57,760 → 00:09:04,680

I want to know like you, you know, if there was more than just drowning because I just

00:09:04,680 → 00:09:12,400

I feel like I'm not sure how deep the river is if she was on the bank of it or what, but

00:09:12,400 → 00:09:18,600

I feel like there is definitely more to it than just drowning.

00:09:18,600 → 00:09:21,960

I wonder why they let William Hammond go free.

00:09:21,960 → 00:09:29,360

I wonder what evidence was lacking, what evidence they did have on him and why he's only been

00:09:29,360 → 00:09:34,680

really the only suspect in this case that I was able to find.

00:09:34,680 → 00:09:41,560

Seeing pictures of Jeremiah on Facebook, on the Facebook page with her family, it honestly

00:09:41,560 → 00:09:47,880

broke my heart doing the research for this case, but it also kind of made me smile because

00:09:47,880 → 00:09:56,720

you can see him and his family smiling through the paint celebrating the cold to this day.

00:09:56,720 → 00:10:02,120

And I honestly just cannot imagine what they've gone through throughout these years, knowing

00:10:02,120 → 00:10:06,600

how easily her case could be solved.

00:10:06,600 → 00:10:11,920

Stay tuned for the next episode where we will be telling you the story of a Marshall student

00:10:11,920 → 00:10:16,000

whose case has left everyone scratching their heads.

00:10:16,000 → 00:10:20,480

If you find yourself enjoying Mountain State Mysteries, give us a five star review and leave

00:10:20,480 → 00:10:23,400

a comment wherever you listen to podcasts.

00:10:23,400 → 00:10:27,920

Don't forget to follow us on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok.

00:10:27,920 → 00:10:30,400

I love Mountain State Mysteries.

00:10:30,400 → 00:10:39,000

If you have a case you want us to cover, send us an email at www.mallonstatemysteries304.com.

00:10:39,000 → 00:10:46,000

For the show notes, check out our website, MountStateMysteriesPodcast.com.

00:11:09,000 → 00:11:16,000

Thank you.

Sorry, your browser isn't supported.

Page load failed