Hamlet is one of William Shakespeare’s finest and most famous masterpieces. On the surface,
it is a classic revenge tragedy. The King of Denmark is murdered, and his son, Prince Hamlet,
must kill the murderer to reclaim the throne. In any other play, the hero would grab a sword
and the story would be over but Hamlet isn't like other heroes. He is a philosopher, a student, and
a man cursed with a brilliant, hyper-active mind. We return to Hamlet because he shows a common
human problem: the more we think, the less we act. He represents the kind of
paralysis where we believe we are being careful, but are actually doing nothing.
Shakespeare describes this state as the “pale cast of thought,” the moment when too much
thinking drains the energy and urgency from an idea that once had the power to change a life.
So if you feel stuck in your own head, constantly weighing options but never actually making a move
it could be because you are suffering from that same "pale cast of thought." which is why we’re
going to take a look at the 6 questions we can extract from Hamlet’s tragedy that,
if answered correctly, might just put an end to your overthinking for good.
Question 1: Is This a "Ghost" or a Reality? The play begins on the cold, dark battlements
of Elsinore Castle. A Ghost, appearing to be Hamlet’s dead father, surfaces from the mist
and it reveals a horrific truth: the King didn't die of a snake bite as everyone believes. He was
murdered by his own brother, Claudius, who poured poison in his ear while he slept. The
Ghost demands that Hamlet take revenge. As we mentioned Hamlet is a scholar. He
immediately begins to doubt his own senses. He thinks: What if this is a demon sent to
tempt me? What if I’m hallucinating out of grief? Because he cannot be 100% sure the Ghost is real,
he does nothing. He does not confront Claudius directly. Instead, he begins a long process of
observation and testing. Hamlet tells himself that once he has undeniable proof, then he will act.
In the meantime, he remains trapped in thought, replaying the situation over and over in his mind.
This mindset is the hallmark of the overthinker. We tell ourselves, “I’ll launch the project once
I’m sure it won’t fail,” or “I’ll commit once I know it’s the right path.” And like Hamlet,
we wait for absolute certainty. Absolute certainty is a myth. Most things that cause
hesitation are “Ghosts” - mental projections fueled by fear rather than concrete reality.
To escape Hamlet’s fate, adopt the 70% Rule. The logic is simple:
If you have about 70% of the information and feel about 70% confident, that is enough to
move forward. The remaining clarity usually comes only after you act. Action is often the only way
to find out whether what you fear is a real problem or just uncertainty holding you back.
Question 2: Am I "Thinking Too Precisely on the Event"?
Halfway through the play, Hamlet is traveling to England when he encounters a young prince named
Fortinbras leading a massive army. These soldiers are marching to fight for a tiny, worthless patch
of land in Poland - a "straw" not even big enough to bury the men who will die for it.
Hamlet is stunned. He watches these men risk everything for a mere shadow of honor,
while he - who has a murdered father, a disgraced mother, and a stolen throne - is
still stuck in his own head, paralyzed by deliberation. He realizes his fatal flaw:
he has been "thinking too precisely on the event." He has been breaking
every goal down into so many sub-scenarios and "what-if" branches that the original spark of
courage is diluted until it becomes cowardice. He has analyzed the problem so thoroughly that
the problem has died on the operating table. In modern psychology, we call this Analysis
Paralysis. It occurs when the fear of making a "wrong" choice leads to making no choice at all.
We take a simple goal - like starting a business, writing a book, or joining a gym - and we slice
it up into a thousand tiny problems. We worry about the taxes, the branding,
the lighting, and the potential for criticism before we’ve even
bought a notebook. This over-analysis creates a "mental friction" that wears down our willpower.
When you make a task complex, you unconsciously give yourself a valid excuse to delay it.
To break the cycle of "thinking too precisely," you must practice Aggressive Simplification.
You have to move from the precision of the event to the essence of it.
So if you find yourself stuck, zoom out and simplify. Reduce the task to the next one step. If
you want to run a marathon, the precision is the sixteen-week, heart-rate-monitored training plan;
the essence is simply putting on your shoes and walking out the front door. When you strip
the task down to its simplest form, you remove the extra paths that fear tends to latch onto.
Question 3: Am I Solving the Problem or Just Watching Myself Think?
Hamlet is paralyzed by doubt, by "what-ifs." So to settle his mind, he hires a troupe of
traveling actors to perform a play called The Murder of Gonzago, but he adds his own lines
to it so that the story mimics exactly how his father was killed, calling the project
"The Mouse-Trap." His goal is to watch King Claudius’s reaction to see if he looks guilty.
He famously tells the actors that the purpose of their art is to "hold the mirror up to nature."
But here is the irony: Hamlet is using the play as a sophisticated stalling tactic.
Instead of confronting the King, he creates a "simulation" of the confrontation. He is an
expert at directing the actors on how to be quote unquote "natural" and "truthful," yet
he cannot be natural or truthful in his own life. He spends the entire play holding that
mirror up to himself - watching himself feel grief, watching himself feel indecision, and
writing poems about his own pain. He has fallen in love with the "intellectual drama" of being a
tortured soul. To Hamlet, being a "deep thinker" has become a more attractive identity than being
a functioning Prince who actually does the work. Now think about your own life: how often do you
hire your own 'troupe of actors'? You buy the books, listen to the podcasts,
and journal for hours about your 'inner block’ - all while avoiding
the one thing that actually moves the needle. We mistakenly believe that the more we understand
our problem, the closer we are to fixing it. But understanding why you are stuck is not the same
thing as getting unstuck. Insight without action is just a form of mental entertainment - you are
essentially becoming a spectator of your own life. Overthinking is a "closed-loop" system. The more
you look inward to find a solution, the more you feed the loop. So to break the mirror, you have
to shift your focus to the external world. When you find yourself "watching yourself
think," stop the internal monologue and pick a physical task that has zero emotional weight.
Clean your desk, lift heavy weights, or finish a boring administrative task. Movement in the
physical world forces your brain to recalibrate based on concrete reality rather than internal
projections. You cannot think your way out of a thinking problem; you have to act your way out.
Question 4: Am I Waiting for the "Perfect" Kill? In his most famous soliloquy, Hamlet utters the
line: "Thus conscience does make cowards of us all." He isn't talking about "conscience" in the
way we use it today - as a moral compass - but rather in the Elizabethan sense:
intense self-consciousness. Hamlet is trapped in a loop of moral perfectionism. He finds his uncle,
Claudius, alone and praying. This is the perfect moment for revenge. But Hamlet stops. He begins
to "conscience" the situation: If I kill him while he is praying, his soul might go to
heaven and that’s not revenge; that’s a favor. By over-moralizing the timing and the "purity"
of the act, he lets the opportunity slip through his fingers. He uses "doing the right thing" as an
excuse to do nothing. What he fails to realize is that once you act, perfection automatically
comes along the way. Perfection is not a prerequisite for movement; it is a destination
reached through the refinement of action. In psychology, this is known as Moral
Decoupling or Perfectionist Procrastination. We often mask our fear of failure as a "high
standard of integrity." We tell ourselves we aren't launching the website because "it’s not
perfectly aligned with our brand values yet," or we don't have the difficult conversation because
"the timing isn't respectful enough" and so on. We believe we are being virtuous and careful,
but in reality, we are using our "conscience" as a guard to keep us safe from the risks of
the real world. Overthinkers often believe that if a move isn't 100% morally or logistically
"perfect," then it shouldn't be made at all. Chasing perfection is often just procrastination.
An imperfect action today is almost always better than a perfect action that never happens.
So don’t ask “Is this the best possible way?”, ask “Is this better than doing nothing?”
"Be not afraid of greatness," Shakespeare wrote elsewhere, but for the overthinker,
the advice should be: "Be not afraid of being 'just okay' - at least it’s a start."
Question 5: Is This "The Ready" or "The Rest"? As we mentioned Hamlet spares Claudius,
reasoning that killing a praying man would cleanse his enemy rather than punish him.
Moments later, Hamlet confronts his mother. Hearing a movement behind the
arras and believing it to be Claudius, he strikes blindly, killing Polonius instead. This single,
impulsive act sets a brutal chain of events in motion: Polonius was the father of Ophelia,
the woman Hamlet loved. Shattered by her father's death at her lover's hands,
she spirals into madness and eventually drowns. Using the blood on Hamlet’s hands as political
leverage, Claudius exiles him to England with secret orders for his execution. Hamlet,
however, survives the treacherous voyage and execution plot, and returns to Elsinore.
By the final act of the play, Hamlet is a changed man. He survived oceans, narrowly escaped an
execution plot, and dealt with the crushing weight of the death of Ophelia. The frantic,
hyper-analytical energy that defined him in the first four acts has burned out,
replaced by a strange, quiet calm. He is invited to a fencing match with
Laertes - Ophelia’s brother, who has returned to Denmark seeking bloody vengeance against
Hamlet. That Hamlet's friend Horatio rightly suspects is a trap. In the earlier scenes,
Hamlet would have spent three monologues weighing the variables, checking for "proof" of the trap,
and agonizing over the "what-ifs." This time, however, he refuses to overthink it.
He tells Horatio: "If it be now, 'tis not to come; if it be not to come, it will be now...
That's all." He finally accepts that he cannot control the "Rest" - the poison on the swords,
the King’s treachery, or the final outcome of his life. He stops trying to solve the
future and focuses entirely on his own internal Readiness to meet whatever the moment brings.
Overthinking is usually a desperate, futile attempt to control the "Rest" - the outcome,
the response of others, or the long-term consequences of a choice. We often suffer
from Predictive Anxiety, where we worry about how our five-year plan will look before we’ve
even mastered our five-minute plan. We think that if we can just anticipate every possible variable,
we can prevent pain or failure. But like Hamlet, we eventually learn that no amount of thinking can
account for the "slings and arrows of outrageous fortune." The more we focus on predicting the
"Rest," the less energy we have for being "Ready." And so to stop worrying about the "Rest,"
you must shift your focus from the external world, which is chaotic,
to your internal state, which you can control. Instead of asking, "What if Scenario X happens?",
ask yourself, "Am I the kind of person who can handle whatever happens?" Shift from Prediction
to Preparation. Invest in the Foundation: Focus on your health, focus on your skills,
on your discipline. If you are physically fit, mentally sharp, and disciplined, you
don’t need to know exactly what the future holds because you are "Ready" for any version of it.
When you focus on your own readiness, you realize that you don't need a map
of the entire forest to take the first step into the trees. To take the first
step into the trees you just need to know that you can handle the hike.
Question 6: To Be, or To Seem? In Hamlet’s most famous line, he asks,
“To be, or not to be?” but counterintuitively, he’s not talking about whether or not to exist,
but rather whether to be real or merely seem real. Nearly every character lives behind a mask.
Claudius, Hamlet’s uncle and the new King of Denmark, seems noble and legitimate but is
secretly a murderer who killed his own brother Gertrude, Hamlet’s mother and the former Queen,
seems like a grieving widow, yet she marries Claudius only weeks after her husband’s death.
Rosencrantz and Guildenstern, two of Hamlet’s childhood friends, seem loyal and concerned for
him, but are actually sent by the King to spy on him and report his behavior.
And so Hamlet eventually becomes trapped in this same world of masks. He obsesses over
how he is perceived - by the court, by his enemies, by his mother, and even by history
itself. He performs the role of the “mad prince” so convincingly that he begins to lose touch with
who he actually is. In trying to manage his image, he ends up abandoning his very being.
In today’s world this tends to show up as social overthinking. Most of our mental noise isn’t
about the work itself - it’s about how we’ll look while doing it. We over-edit messages,
rehearse conversations, and delay action because we’re afraid of seeming foolish, unqualified,
or just imperfect. But the bitter irony is that we perform for an audience that is too distracted
with their own insecurities to notice. The solution is Radical Authenticity.
Stop asking, “How will this be perceived?” and start asking,
“Is this true to me?” When your actions align with what you actually believe and value,
overthinking collapses. There’s no mask to maintain and no role to rehearse. A
person who is simply being doesn’t need to manage appearances - they are too busy doing the work.
After five acts of delay, doubt, and "watching himself think," Hamlet finally achieves his
goal - but at the highest possible price. He does eventually kill his uncle, Claudius,
but it isn't through some calculated, masterful plan. Instead, he acts only when he is cornered,
poisoned, and has mere minutes left to live. In the final scene, Hamlet’s mother is dead
from drinking poisoned wine meant for him. Hamlet himself has been struck by a poisoned blade. It is
only in this moment of total desperation - when he no longer has the luxury to "think precisely
on the event" - that he finally stabs the King. Hamlet slays his uncle, but he dies immediately
after. Because he waited for the "perfect" certainty, the "perfect" plan, and the "perfect"
moment, he lost his mother, his friends, his kingdom, and his life. He cleared the "pale
cast of thought" only when death forced his hand. The tragedy of Hamlet is not that he never acts,
but that he waits until action can no longer save him. The lesson is simple:
don’t wait until everything is already falling apart before you move. At that
point, you’re not choosing—you’re just reacting.
And that's our video. What did you think? Let’s get into it in the comments. As always,
I've been Dan, you've been awesome, and if you enjoyed this video, please make sure to check out
our full philosophies for life playlist. And for more videos to help you find success and happiness
using beautiful philosophical wisdom, don't forget to subscribe. Thanks so much for watching.