How Matt Richards Went From Youth Pastor & Father To Homicidal Maniac

Oct 02, 2023, 11:00 PM

What could possibly drive a youth pastor, a man sworn to the moral teachings of faith and community, to violently attack his own wife and children? This chilling question recently gripped listeners of the podcast "Hidden Killers" as Tony Brueski and Psychologist John Delatorre delved deep into the case of Matthew Lee Richards.
 Richards, in the throes of financial despair and facing imminent eviction, attempted to murder his wife and five children, all of whom, astoundingly, survived the ordeal. Brueski was quick to draw parallels with another infamous case: "Just as we had talked about with Alex Murdaugh, everybody was surprised and shocked at how could a father kill their family or go after them in such a heinous way because of finances."
 Delatorre analyzed the psychology behind such grim actions: "In this guy's mind, he's clearly thinking that being evicted is the worst thing that's ever going to happen to them. In reality, that's not true." He expounded on the pressure many men often feel, coupled with an inability to communicate or express their anxieties, that can lead them down a path of isolation and eventual breakdown.
 One of the most jarring revelations in the discussion was that none of the family members were even aware of the looming eviction. Richards hadn't shared a word about their financial predicament. This glaring absence of communication raised probing questions. Delatorre pondered, "This could have been very easily solved had the two communicated? Had he talked to his wife about the problems that were going on?" But instead, Richards's silence and subsequent violent actions suggested either a premeditated plan or a spontaneous mental break.
 The intricacies of the attack, however, don't paint a clear picture. Despite the severe injuries inflicted on his family, such as his son’s exposed internal organs or another’s slashed throat, everyone miraculously survived. Was this another of Richards's failures, or was there an underlying hesitation in his actions? Delatorre’s assessment was blunt: "I think that he was just a failure."
 The episode underscored the complex interplay between financial pressure, societal expectations, and the male psyche. Delatorre highlighted the importance of open communication, both with partners and within communities, to prevent such tragic events.
 "By avoiding it, he certainly made the problem a lot worse," Delatorre observed. He further emphasized the significance of reaching out, saying, "had he just been open and honest about everything that was going on from the beginning... he probably could have avoided a lot of issues."
 In today’s society, where the facades of social media often mask the raw, uncomfortable realities of life, the case of Matthew Lee Richards serves as a chilling reminder of the consequences that can result from internalizing struggles.
 A Failed Attempt or a Cry for Help?
 Despite the gruesome nature of Richards's assault, all his family members lived. Does this fact offer any deeper insight into Richards's mental state during the attack? Was there a hidden ambivalence in his intent? Did he truly wish to annihilate his family, or was there a subconscious desire for them to survive? And if this were the case, was his violent outbreak a plea for intervention or a desperate cry for help?
 These harrowing questions remain, emphasizing the need for society to remain vigilant, compassionate, and supportive, especially towards those showing signs of distress.

Want to listen to ALL of our podcasts AD-FREE? Subscribe through APPLE PODCASTS, and try it for three days free:
Follow Our Other Cases:
The latest on Catching the Long Island Serial Killer, Awaiting Admission: BTK’s Unconfessed Crimes, Chad & Lori Daybell, The Murder of Ana Walshe, Alex Murdaugh, Bryan Kohberger, Lucy Letby, Kouri Richins, Justice for Harmony Montgomery, The Murder of Stephen Smith, The Murder of Madeline Kingsbury, and much more! Listen at