Right of First Refusal Explained (It's Bad)
Share
Subscribe
Has your ex been following the rules so far in this divorce? No?
Then what the hell makes you think they'll follow the right of first refusal clause—spoiler: they won't, but you will, and that's exactly how this bullshit clause destroys you.
Has your ex been following the rules so far in this divorce? No?
Then what the hell makes you think they'll follow the right of first refusal clause—spoiler: they won't, but you will, and that's exactly how this bullshit clause destroys you.
Right of first refusal is one of the biggest mistakes you can make in a high-conflict divorce. I've lived it, I've coached hundreds through it, and I'm sick of watching good parents get screwed by this clause.
Here's what actually happens: You need to attend a childfree wedding, so you call your ex per the clause. They're like, "Oh yeah! I'd love extra time with the kids! Go have fun!" You go, have a good time, come back the next day—and your kids are walking out with their heads down. "Dad said you chose partying over us." And your ex hits you with: "I'm gonna use this against you in court."
Wait. What the actual f? Twelve hours ago they were all about that extra time. Now it's ammunition.
And here's the kicker: Your ex will never follow this rule themselves. While you're being the perfect rule follower, they're leaving your kids with their new girlfriend for three days straight. With the neighbor lady. With their mom. With literally anyone except offering you the time first. You'll catch them, have proof, and they'll say "Oh, I forgot" or "It was only a few hours." They will not follow the rules. Ever. But you will.
What We're Covering:
- How right of first refusal actually works - And why it only works against you
- Real weaponization examples - Including my scuba trip story that became a child support argument
- Why you can't control who watches your kids anyway - You lost that at "divorce"
- How this eliminates your support system - No grandparents, babysitters, or village help
- The perspective shift - Your kids will figure out who's actually showing up
- Life happens - Work trips, emergencies, dates, parent-teacher conferences—shit happens
- The money angle - They'll use "extra time" for child support modifications
How to negotiate leaving it out - Show them how it restricts them too
The Truth:
You're looking at 50/50 custody. You know who else only gets 50% access now? Grandma. Your best friend. Your entire village. And if you include right of first refusal? Those people can't help you at all. No sleepovers at grandma's. No friend sleepovers. Nothing. Your high-conflict ex will be that petty.
Courts won't referee this. File contempt in January, get a hearing in March, and by then they've cleaned up their act. "Just that one time, Your Honor." Meanwhile you followed every rule and they broke every single one.
Let Me Save You Some Serious Pain:
Don't put right of first refusal in your parenting plan. Period.
I don't care if your lawyer says it's "standard." I don't care if it sounds fair. Don't do it. You'll be the only one following it. Your ex will weaponize it. Your kids will be told you don't prioritize them. You'll lose your support system.
If you're dying on this hill, check out my Parenting Plan Masterclass with Playbook for the do's and don'ts. But I'm telling you: you will regret it.
My Advice (And I Really Mean This):
Change your perspective. Accept you can't control what happens during their time. You can't stop the new girlfriend from babysitting. You can't control any of it. Take it off your list.
Your kids will figure out who's actually showing up and who's dumping them constantly. When they realize they're always with grandma instead of mom, or the girlfriend instead of dad, they're getting a fast education in reality. That's not hurting you—that's helping them see the truth.
Time is all you've got with your kids. Don't waste yours by following rules your ex never will.
Here’s What You Can Actually Take Away:
- You'll Be the Only Rule Follower - You're following right of first refusal religiously while your ex is leaving the kids with their new girlfriend for three days straight and never offering you anything.
- This Clause Eliminates Your Village - Say goodbye to babysitters, help from grandma, friend sleepovers, and emergency backup. Your entire support system gets cut off during your parenting time.
- Courts Won't Referee This Bullshit - By the time you get a contempt hearing months later, they've cleaned up their act and it's "just that one time, Your Honor." You have proof of 14 violations and nothing happens.
- Your Kids Will Figure It Out - When they're constantly dumped with grandma or the girlfriend instead of actually spending time with that parent, your kids are getting a fast education in who really shows up.
Life Happens and You WILL Need Help - Work trips, weddings, emergencies, parent-teacher conferences, dates, three days of diarrhea. You can't predict when you'll need to step away, and this clause makes everything impossible.
- High-conflict people will leave kids with neighbors before they'll ever follow the rules of right of first refusal, that's just the ugly truth.
- You're going through a divorce and your kids now only see grandparents, aunts, uncles, and friends 50% of the time. Don't make it worse by saying those people can't help you either.
- They'll happily take the extra time with the kids, then turn around and tell your children you chose partying over them and threaten to use it against you in court.
- Right of first refusal clauses sound really good until they wreck your life because you'll be the only one following the rules while your ex breaks every single one.
- The perspective I want you to have is: can't stop it, can't control it, take it off your list. Your kids will figure out who's actually there for them.
Follow Samantha Boss: